Welcome to Collectors Coins & Jewelry in Staten Island – Your Local Experts in Appraisals & Buying Services

Schedule Your Appraisal
Collectors-Coins-and-Jewelry-Old-Bridge image 37

Our Commitment to Excellence

Trusted Appraisals, Exceptional Service

Your trusted local experts for professional appraisals and immediate buying services.

Collectors Coins & Jewelry proudly serves Staten Island with the same trusted appraisal process and customer-first approach that has defined our business for decades. Whether you’re looking to sell gold, silver, coins, jewelry, diamonds, or luxury watches, our experienced team provides accurate evaluations, transparent pricing, and immediate offers in a secure and professional environment. From single items to entire estates, we make the selling process straightforward, educational, and stress-free. Our reputation is built on honesty, expertise, and long-standing relationships with our clients.

Whether you’re selling inherited items, upgrading your collection, or simply turning valuables into cash, our team is here to guide you every step of the way.
Schedule Your Appraisal
Collectors-Coins-and-Jewelry-Old-Bridge image 37
How to Let Go of Inherited Jewelry Without Guilt - Expert Tips

Discover Collectors Coins & Jewelry in Staten Island

Watch our team in action as we guide you through our appraisal process and showcase our welcoming store environment. Build trust with our experts and learn how we ensure the best value for your valuables.

About Us

We’re Here to Buy What Matters to You.

We purchase a wide range of valuables, including:

  • Gold Jewelry & Bullion
  • Sterling Silver & Flatware
  • Luxury Watches
  • Coins & Currency
  • Diamonds & Fine Jewelry

Explore each category to learn more about what we buy and how our appraisal process works.

What We Buy

Jewelry Appraisals

Bring in your exquisite fine jewelry for a thorough and professional evaluation by our certified and licensed professionals who will provide you with a fair and competitive offer. We are committed to ensuring that you receive the best possible market value for your pieces, allowing you to feel confident in your decision.

Gold & Silver Buying

Discover unbeatable rates for gold and silver, whether you’re looking to sell coins or flatware. At Collectors Coins & Jewelry – Staten Island, we pride ourselves on offering exceptional prices that reflect the latest market trends, ensuring you receive the value you deserve.

Luxury Watch Purchases

We buy luxury watches from top brands like Rolex, Patek Philippe, Audemars Piguet, Omega and Cartier. Trust our specialists for accurate appraisals.

Coin Appraisals

Offering competitive prices for rare and collectible coins. Our team provides detailed evaluations for your collection.

How It Works – A Straightforward, Transparent Process

Whether you’re selling gold, jewelry, watches, or coins, we make the process straightforward and rewarding. Here’s what you can expect from start to finish.

Step 1

Schedule Your Visit
Book an appointment online or contact us directly. Walk-ins are welcome, and all evaluations are free and no-obligation.
Schedule Your Appraisal

Step 2

Expert Evaluation
Our experienced appraisers carefully examine your items using industry-standard tools and current market pricing. Items are evaluated in front of you — nothing ever leaves your sight.

Step 3

Receive an Offer
You’ll receive a transparent, competitive offer based on weight, purity, condition, brand, rarity, and market demand.

Step 4

Get Paid
Accept the offer and receive immediate payment. No pressure, no hidden fees — just straightforward service.

Sell with Confidence and Unlock the True Value of Your Valuables Today!

How to Let Go of Inherited Jewelry Without Guilt - Expert Tips
Collectors-Coins-and-Jewelry-Old-Bridge image 37

What People Are Saying

Check Out Our Reviews

Latisha Scott

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
(5/5)
I have visited this company several times and each visit leaves me smiling! Anthony, who shares my birthday, has always been incredibly helpful and professional. Based on my experiences, I wholeheartedly recommend their services. They are welcoming and consistently deliver excellence! I'll see you guys soon when I find some more goodies in my house!

H Smith

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
(5/5)
This place is true to its word! They give you top dollar compared to most other places that give you cash for gold/silver. I went there Friday amd had a great experience with Cory one of the owners. Great guy! I brought a couple of my kids with me and they were ridiling him with questions and he patiently answered all there questions. Great experience!

Cassandra Generelli

☆☆☆☆☆
★★★★★
(5/5)
This seller is absolutely wonderful! I purchased a watch for my husband and they were communicative, helpful, and so easy to work with. I would highly recommend working with Coin Collectors and will do so again in the future!

Get Started Now

"